Underdog Fantasy in Ohio: Legal? Here's Everything You Need!

6 minutes on read

Ohio's gaming regulations, an area of ongoing legislative focus, directly impact the availability of platforms like Underdog Fantasy. Daily Fantasy Sports (DFS), a category that Underdog Fantasy operates within, faces specific legal scrutiny based on interpretations of skill-based gaming versus chance. This detailed examination of the existing statutes helps clarify the pivotal question: is underdog fantasy legal in ohio? Understanding the role of the Ohio Casino Control Commission in overseeing gaming activities is crucial for players and operators alike.

Sports Betting in Ohio - Road Trip Tour of Top Ohio Legal Sportsbooks

Image taken from the YouTube channel Lineups US , from the video titled Sports Betting in Ohio - Road Trip Tour of Top Ohio Legal Sportsbooks .

This guide provides a comprehensive analysis of the legality of Underdog Fantasy in Ohio. Understanding the nuances of Ohio's gaming laws is crucial to determining whether or not participating in Underdog Fantasy contests is permissible. This explanation delves into the relevant legislation, provides context, and offers a clear picture of the current legal landscape.

Defining Underdog Fantasy and Daily Fantasy Sports (DFS)

Before examining the legal status, it's important to clarify what Underdog Fantasy is and how it relates to Daily Fantasy Sports (DFS).

  • Underdog Fantasy: Operates primarily using a "pick'em" style format. Users select "over" or "under" for projected statistical performances of athletes.
  • Daily Fantasy Sports (DFS): Traditionally involves building a roster of athletes within a salary cap and competing against other users based on the real-world performance of those athletes in a specific timeframe (daily or weekly).

While Underdog Fantasy is often categorized under the broader umbrella of DFS, its distinct format can impact its legal classification.

Ohio's Gaming Laws and DFS

Ohio has specific legislation addressing fantasy sports, primarily aimed at the more traditional DFS model.

Key Legislation: House Bill 29

  • House Bill 29 (HB 29), signed into law, specifically legalized sports gaming in Ohio. This included provisions for traditional Daily Fantasy Sports.
  • Licensing and Regulation: HB 29 established a framework for licensing and regulating DFS operators within the state.
  • Taxation: DFS operators are subject to specific tax rates on their revenue generated in Ohio.

To legally operate in Ohio under the DFS framework established by HB 29, operators must typically adhere to criteria such as:

  1. Skill-Based Contests: The games must be determined to be games of skill, not chance.
  2. Prize Structures: Prizes must be clearly defined and compliant with state regulations.
  3. Consumer Protection: Measures must be in place to protect consumers, including responsible gaming initiatives and age verification.

The legality of Underdog Fantasy in Ohio is not explicitly defined in the current legislation due to its "pick'em" format.

Arguments for Legality

  • Skill-Based Argument: Proponents argue that selecting "over/under" on player statistics requires skill and knowledge, falling within the realm of permissible skill-based contests.
  • Parimutuel Wagering Similarity: Some argue it resembles parimutuel wagering, where the payout depends on the total amount wagered on a particular outcome. While not exactly the same, the principle of predicting outcomes based on skill could be similar.

Arguments Against Legality/Potential Risks

  • Sports Betting Resemblance: Opponents argue that "pick'em" contests closely resemble proposition bets or player props offered by traditional sportsbooks, which require separate licensure and are subject to different regulations.
  • Lack of Specific Clarity in HB 29: HB 29 doesn't explicitly address formats like Underdog's "pick'em" contests, leaving room for interpretation.

Potential Interpretations by the Ohio Casino Control Commission

The Ohio Casino Control Commission (OCCC) is responsible for regulating gaming in Ohio. Their interpretation is crucial.

Consideration Potential OCCC Interpretation Impact on Underdog Fantasy
Skill vs. Chance Evaluation If the OCCC determines "pick'em" contests rely more on chance than skill, it could be deemed illegal under current DFS regulations. Underdog Fantasy could be required to obtain a different type of license (sports betting) or cease operations in Ohio.
Resemblance to Sports Betting If the OCCC finds a strong resemblance to sports betting, Underdog Fantasy may need to comply with sports betting licensing requirements. Underdog Fantasy would need to navigate the more stringent requirements and higher taxes associated with sports betting licenses.
Need for Updated Regulations/Clarification The OCCC might release updated regulations or formal statements clarifying the legality of these contests. This could provide definitive guidance for Underdog Fantasy and other similar platforms operating in Ohio, allowing them to adjust their offerings to remain compliant.

What Should Ohio Residents Do?

  • Stay Informed: Keep abreast of any updates or rulings from the Ohio Casino Control Commission regarding DFS and similar platforms.
  • Understand the Risks: Be aware that the legal status is currently uncertain, and regulations may change.
  • Gamble Responsibly: Regardless of the legal status, practice responsible gaming habits.
So, there you have it! Hopefully, this has cleared up any confusion surrounding whether is underdog fantasy legal in ohio. Good luck, have fun, and always play responsibly!